The Menu Museum
DecadesRestaurantsDishesRandom menu

Anthony's Pier 4

Anthony's Pier 4; 140 Northern Avenue

Restaurant
Anthony's Pier 4
Place
Anthony's Pier 4; 140 Northern Avenue
Venue
RESTAURANT
Physical description
Tri-fold; 9.75 x 16 inches; laminated
Currency
Dollars

Pages

  1. Page 1
  2. Page 2
  3. Page 3
  4. Page 4
  5. Page 5
  6. Page 6

Dishes

Page 1

Lobster Bisque$6.95
New England Clam Chowder$3.95
Boston Fish Chowder$3.95
Bouillabaisse for Two$8.95
Oysters on the half shell$7.95
Cherrystone Clams on the Half Shell$7.95
Littleneck Clams on the Half Shell$7.95
Shrimp Cocktail$8.95
New England Raw Bar Platter, A Platter of Oysters, Cherrystones, Littlenecks and Shrimp Served with Lemon, Horseradish, Our Own Cocktail Sauce and Mignonette Sauce$11.95
Our Own Smoked Salmon, Apple and Maple Cured Fresh Atlantic Salmon Smoked over Applewood$11.95
Fresh Salmon Gravlax, Dill Cured Fresh Atlantic Salmon. Served with Honey Mustard Sauce$11.95
Boston Sashimi, The Freshest of Raw Fish including Tuna, Salmon, Swordfish, Finnan Haddie, Scallops, Oyster, Cherrystone, Pickled Ginger, Wasabi and Soy Sauce$11.95
Fresh Native Crabmeat Cocktail$7.95
Fresh Florida Stone Crab Claws (in season)$12.95
Native Crabmeat Cake, Served with Tomato-Olive Beurre Blanc$7.95
Baked Clams a la Anthony$6.95
Baked Oysters a la Rockefeller$7.95
Escargots Bourguignonne$7.95
Shrimp Scampi$8.95
Steamed clams$9.95
Steamed Mussels, Steamed in White Wine, Garlic and Shallots$8.95
Malossol Caviar, One Ounce Served with Sour Cream, Diced Onions and Capers$25.95
Baked Stuffed Lobster a la Hawthorne, Glover salad and potato$26.95 – $36.95
Lobster Newburg, Glover salad and potato$21.95
Boiled Live Lobster, Glover salad and potato$19.95 – $29.95
Baked Lobster Savannah$29.95
Our Featured Lobsters - Boiled or Broiled, Three to Four and One Half Pounds and Larger, Glover salad and potato$15.95
Anthony's Pier 4 Clambake Special, Whole Boiled Lobster, Shrimp, Steamed Clams, Mussels, Drawn Butter and Clam Broth, Glover salad and potato$26.95
BROILED LIVE LOBSTER, Glover salad and potato$19.95 – $29.95

Page 2

Broiled Famous Boston Scrod, Fresh from the Waters of Georges Bank, Glover Salad and Potato or Rice$14.95
Baked Stuffed Filet of Sole, Served with Lobster Newburg Sauce, Glover Salad and Potato or Rice$14.95
Baked Finnan Haddie, Haddock Smoked Especially for Anthony's Pier 4, Baked Slowly in Fresh Milk and Topped with Butter, Glover Salad and Potato or Rice$15.95
Baked Stuffed Shrimp, Glover Salad and Potato or Rice$18.95
Baked Shrimp Rockefeller, Glover Salad and Potato or Rice$15.95
Shrimp Scampi, Glover Salad and Potato or Rice$16.95
Sauteed Native Grey Sole, Glover Salad and Potato or Rice$16.95
Broiled Georges Bank Sea Scallops, Glover Salad and Potato or Rice$16.95
Oven Roasted Seafood Combination, Includes Shrimp, Salmon, Swordfish, Scallops, Polenta and Zucchini. Served with Lime-Chieve Beurre Blanc, Glover Salad and Potato or Rice$19.95
Poached Filet of Atlantic Salmon, Served with Dill Sauce, Julienne of Vegetables, and Fresh Peas, Glover Salad and Potato or Rice$16.95
Fresh Native Crabmeat Cakes, Served with Tomato-Olive Beurre Blanc, Glover Salad and Potato or Rice$15.95
Fresh Blackened Tuna, Cajun Style, Glover Salad and Potato or Rice$16.95
Fresh Sauteed Halibut, with Raspberry Vinegar Sauce, Glover Salad and Potato or Rice$18.95
Fresh Whole Dover Sole, Saute Meuniere, Glover Salad and Potato or Rice$26.95
Bouillabaisse a la Marseillaise, Shellfish and Finfish Combined in a Broth of Fresh Tomatoes, Leeks, Garlic and Saffron. Served with Garlic Bread and Glover Salad$19.95
Bouillabaisse a la Marseillaise, Shellfish and Finfish Combined in a Broth of Fresh Tomatoes, Leeks, Garlic and Saffron. Served with Garlic Bread and Glover Salad, with Half Lobster$27.95
Fresh Swordfish, Served with Tomato-Olive Beurre Blanc, Glover Salad and Potato or Rice$19.95
Fresh Yellowfin Tuna, Served with Lime-Chive Beurre Blanc, Glover Salad and Potato or Rice$16.95
Fresh Atlantic Salmon, Served with Spicy Fruit Chutney, Glover Salad and Potato or Rice$16.95
Fresh Halibut, Served with Lime-Chive Beurre Blanc, Glover Salad and Potato or Rice$18.95

Page 3

Prime New York Sirloin, Glover Salad and Potato$24.95
Filet Mignon, Glover Salad and Potato$24.95
Specially Aged Prime 18 Ounce New York Sirloin, Glover Salad and Potato$34.95
Roast Heavy Steer Prime Ribs of Beef, Au Jus, Glover Salad and Potato$18.95
Grilled Veal chop, Glover Salad and Potato$25.95
Roast Rack of Lamb for One, Glover Salad and Potato$21.95
Ratatouille Provencale$3.50
Fresh Broccoli Hollandaise$3.95
French Fried Onion Rings$3.95
Charcoal Broiled Onions$3.95
Anthony's Creamed Spinach$3.95
Broiled Mushrooms$3.95
Marinated Mushrooms$3.95
Watercress Salad$3.95
Hearts of Palm, Vinaigrette$4.95
Artichoke hearts, Vinaigrette$4.95
Fried Oysters, Freshly opened to your order, French Fried Potatoes and Cole Slaw$16.95
Fried Filet of Sole, French Fried Potatoes and Cole Slaw$14.95
Fried Georges Bank Sea Scallops, French Fried Potatoes and Cole Slaw$16.95
FRIED SHRIMP, French Fried Potatoes and Cole Slaw$15.95
Pier 4 Fisherman's Platter, A Generous Platter of Golden Fried Native Sole, Cod, Monk Fish, Scallops, Shrimp and Oyster, French Fried Potatoes and Cole Slaw$19.95
Grand Mariner Souffle, Served with Zabaglione Sauce$5.95
Choclate Souffle, Served with Zabaglione$5.95
Cigars
Bearnaise or Mushroom Sauce on Request

Page 4

Fresh Native Crabmeat Cakes, Served with Tomato-Olive Beurre Blanc$7.95
Chicken of the Day, Glover Salad and Rice or Choice of Potato$13.95
Thai Basil Shrimp, Served with Spicy Thai Sauce, Jasmine Rice and Glover Salad$17.95
Sake Poached Atlantic Salmon, Served in an Aromatic Broth and Topped with Ginger - Cilantro Green Sauce, Served with Jasmine Rice and Glover Salad$17.95
Sauteed Shrimp with Spicy Tomato Sauce, Served with Jasmine Rice and Glover Salad$17.95
Fresh Deep Dish Blueberry Pie, Served with Vanilla Ice Cream$3.95
Chocolate Espresso Cake, Served with Raspberry Sauce$4.50
FRESH NATIVE CRABMEAT CAKES Served with Tomato-Olive Beurre Blanc, Glover Salad and Rice or Choice of Potato$15.95

Source: NYPL Digital Collections

16,525 menus · 64,352 scanned pages · 1851–2008 · uncatalogued scans

Scans and transcription data from the New York Public Library’s What’s on the Menu? project. This site is not affiliated with NYPL.